Custard Cottage Cheese Pie, Mrs. Henry W Lenz

Slice of custard cottage cheese pie smearcase cheesecake with cinnamon sugar topping on white plate, homemade dessert

I recently had the privilege of giving a talk at the Homewood Museum on Johns Hopkins University’s campus. I focused on Baltimore’s culinary history, but or course there was plenty about Maryland in general.

After the talk, someone asked a question about the influence of immigrants on Maryland cuisine. “Honestly,” I said, “if I had just watched my talk and were to critique it, I would say it didn’t have enough emphasis on the impact of German Marylanders.”

It hadn’t really struck me until that moment. Yes, I always mention German immigration to Baltimore, and the Pennsylvania Dutch cusine in Maryland. But it’s only in the past few years that I’ve considered the long legacy of Germans on the regions west of Baltimore.

Thanks to Smearcase and Kinklings, I’ve found myself on the genealogical path of many families and communities who settled into lives of agriculture in our state.

St. Paul’s Lutheran Church in Upperco has a historical marker denoting it as the oldest Lutheran congregation in Baltimore County. Its recorded history dates back to 1794.

Historic brick church with white steeple and arched windows in black and white photograph. — *St. Paul’s Lutheran Church, MD Historical Trust*

Glady’s Clements Lenz is buried in the St. Paul’s Cemetery along with her husband Henry, and her parents, Hazel and Oliver Clements.

Gladys contributed two recipes to “Cook and Tell,” a cookbook produced by the Arcadia Ladies Auxiliary Vol. Fire Co. in 1945. One of her recipes is for Strawberry Cake and the other is for this Custard Cottage Cheese Pie, which struck me as a variation of Baltimore’s beloved smearcase cheesecake. Glady’s family lineage traces back to generations of farmers in Maryland.

Gladys was born in 1917 in Baltimore but lived most of her life in Upperco. She died in 1999. Her findagrave memorial states that she descended from the Upperco family for which the town was named. According to the German Marylanders website, the name is an Americanization of the German “Opferkuchen.” Gladys’ few newspaper mentions are related to the 1995 death of her husband Henry, who was a member of the Order of the Eastern Star.

Henry, as evident by his own last name, has German grandparents on one side and great-grandparents on the other.

Weathered gravestone with carved inscriptions and lichen growth in cemetery grass — *findagrave.com*

We can never know the true origin of Gladys’ recipe, but it turned out a pie with a similar texture to smearcase. I made sure to find cottage cheese that was free from thickeners like guar gum.

I’d want to give this one a try again to compare and contrast with Carolyn Yingling’s “Cheese Cake,” but both recipes offer some advances over other internet smearcase cheesecake recipes I previously tried.

Starting with the hand carved 1798 tombstone of Johann Wilhelm “William” Eltzroth, the cemetery of St. Paul’s Lutheran is the final resting place for generations of German Marylanders and their families. Their influence lives on in the food we eat in Baltimore and beyond.

Recipe:

Baking ingredients for custard cottage cheese pie smearcase cheesecake variation including milk, sugar, eggs, cottage cheese, and paste on wooden surface

1 cup cottage cheese
1 cup sugar
2 eggs
2 Tablespoons flour (rounded)
1 tsp vanilla
2 c milk
1/4 tsp salt

Mash cottage cheese. Add flour, sugar, salt, vanilla, and beaten egg yolk. Stir in milk. Lastly add beaten egg whites. Pour into 9″ unbaked pie shell. Bake at 450° for 10 minutes, then 300° for 35 minutes.

Recipe adapted from Cook and Tel, Arcadia Ladies Auxiliary Vol. Fire Co., Upperco, MD. 1945.