Southern Sour Milk Biscuits, Mary Helen Dove & Mary Taylor

From Beef Broth to Banana Fritters, one of my favorite cookbooks to turn to for everyday recipes is “300 Years of Black Cooking in St. Mary’s County.” No book better encapsulates the range of delicious fare produced in the kitchens of Maryland’s home cooks.

As much as I love “Maryland’s Way” and “Eat, Drink & Be Merry in Maryland,” those books contain recipes from the state’s wealthiest families. The Canvasback Duck and Terrapin served in elite hotels and manors may have made our regional food famous, but the culinary talents behind those dishes was an outgrowth of the brilliant and humble cooking traditions captured in the “300 Years.”

Compiled in 1975 by “Citizens for Progress,” the book contains recipes from over 60 residents of St. Mary’s County. There is a history of stuffed ham included, with two different recipes. By far the most recipes were contributed by Theresa Young, whose daughter I spoke to a few years ago for this post.

Sometimes I feel like “300 Years of Black Cooking in St. Mary’s County” is kind of a crutch – a very easy book to turn to when I want to focus on African-American cooking in Maryland. We (historians, Marylanders, whatever…) are very lucky to have a document like this.

On the other hand, the book really is so great that it deserves repeat readings (and cookings.) This time around, I made “Southern Sour Milk Biscuits,” attributed to Mary Helen Dove and Mary Taylor.

Unfortunately, I couldn’t definitively identify either person. It is possible that Mary Helen Dove was a woman who was born around 1897 and passed away in Baltimore in 1981.

A farming family’s home interior, Beachville, MD, 1940, Jack Delano, loc.gov

Whether or not that is true, I often find evidence that the extended families associated with “300 Years” had connections in Baltimore city. Some moved to the city later in life, others would visit with family in Baltimore during the summer. This suggests the influence that the unique culture of Southern Maryland has had on the city I call home.

The concept of urban versus rural implies a lot of arbitrary cultural differences that should be questioned, especially in light of the series of events that have displaced or hindered generations of farmers (black and white).

During and after the Civil War, many Confederates fled Maryland. One was Joseph Forrest, who was a captain of the “Fourth Maryland Light Artillery.” In 1864, Forrest’s abandoned land was seized by General Lew Wallace for use by the Freedmen’s Bureau.

The purpose of the Bureau was to protect former slaves and provide living quarters and a livelihood where possible… These plantations were called ‘Government Farms.’ The only properties abandoned and seized in all of Maryland were in St. Mary’s County.” – Maryland Historic Trust

House and garden of William Sanders, Farm Security Administration Saint Inigoes, Maryland, Jack Delano 1940, loc.gov

All in all, the Freedmen’s Bureau in St. Mary’s County seized 3000 acres of land for 500 Black citizens to farm. When President Andrew Johnson granted amnesty to the exiled Confederates who had once claimed the land, the white planters got to take the land back. Forrest was pardoned in 1865.

Most Black farmers were tenant farmers or sharecroppers. Those who were able to get land for themselves were often displaced by other circumstances, as in the heartbreaking case of the Dyson family.

My attempts to identify Mary Helen Dove or Mary Taylor entailed another viewing of “Now When I Look Back,” by Andrea Hamer, a book of oral histories and Farm Security Administration photos. I strongly recommend you get yourself to the Maryland Room at the Enoch Pratt Free Library and spend some time with this book. It’s a meditation on history’s legacy, the earth’s bounty, perseverance, and community bonds. All of the things that make Maryland’s history – and our food – so fascinating.

Recipe:

  • 2 Cups flour
  • .5 Teaspoon baking soda
  • 1 Teaspoon baking powder
  • 1 Teaspoon salt
  • 4 Tablespoon shortening
  • 1 Cup thick sour milk*

Sift together the dry ingredients. Cut in the shortening. Stir in the milk. Roll to 1/2″ thick on a floured surface. Cut, place on a greased or parchment-covered sheet. Bake at 425°  for 15-17 minutes.

Modern pasteurized milk generally doesn’t get sour in an appetizing way. If it’s a little off it may be used. I used a mix of milk, yogurt, and beer and left it out overnight to get a nice ‘funk.’

Recipe adapted from “300 Years of Black Cooking in St. Mary’s County”

Elizabeth Ellicott Lea’s Smearcase

This isn’t the official Smearcase post- that’s to come later. (Update: Click here for Official Smearcase Post) This is just a brief post with two recipes from Elizabeth Ellicott Lea’s book. I thought they might offer some insight into the history of smearcase.

Many Baltimoreans know “Smearcase” as a beloved cheesecake of German origin, available at many of the same bakeries that peddle Peach Cakes. Much like Baltimore Peach Cake, Smearcase has enjoyed a fair share of nostalgic press. The word “smearcase,” readers may know, referred originally to the cheese that this cake was made from. That is what the word meant to Elizabeth Ellicott Lea.

I had some milk that had gone a little off so I decided to try and make use of it. Modern cottage cheese advice suggested adding a little acid, in the form of vinegar or lemon juice, to curdle the milk. I opted for that method. Modern milk is pasteurized, and so I was essentially working with a different ingredient than Lea would have been.

By 1845, when Lea’s book was published, the recipe was named “Cheese Cake,” but in truth, cheesecake is more the direct descendent of pudding than any cake. Most early American cookbooks and their English predecessors have recipes for making “curd” or “cheese puddings”.

This recipe was about as close to hearth cooking as it gets in my kitchen, owing to a lack of air-conditioning on a very hot day. The buttercrust had to be worked quickly, and it looks quite “rustic” as a result. It is humbling to think of the ways that experienced hearth cooks of the past would cope with these challenges.

Even with the 19th-century flavors (rose water and currants), the pie was suitable for a modern sweet tooth. The cheesemaking process, however, is a little unappetizing looking, so don’t be surprised if this post makes you want to swear off dairy…

image

“Cottage Cheese, or Smearcase

The best plan of making this dish, is to set the tinpan of clabber on a hot stove, or in a pot of water that is boiling over the fire. When the whey has risen sufficiently, pour it through a colander, and put the curd or cheese away in a cold place, and just before going to table, season it with salt and pepper to your taste, and pour some sweet cream over it.”

image
image
image
image
image

“Cheese Cakes

Take one quart of curd, after the whey has been strained off, mix with it half a pound of fresh butter, an ounce of pounded blanched almonds, the whites of three eggs, a tea-cup of currants; season with sugar and rose water to your taste, and bake in plates with paste.”

image
image
image
image
image

Recipes from “Domestic cookery, useful receipts, and hints to young housekeepers” by ELizabeth Ellicott Lea

image
Scroll to top
error: Content is protected !!