Baltimore Peach Cake**

Homemade Baltimore Peach Cake with cinnamon sugar and fresh peach slices in baking pan next to Black-Eyed Susan Country cookbook

This recipe for an alternate version of Baltimore Peach Cake** comes from “Black-Eyed Susan Country,” another popular Maryland fund-raising cookbook.

This particular book, first printed in 1987, raised money for St. Agnes Hospital. Onetime St. Agnes Auxiliary president Mary Parga was a volunteer at the White House, and used her connections to compile the book’s notable “VIP” section. Barbara Mikulski’s crab-cake recipe makes an appearance, as well as [William Donald] “Schaefer’s Wafers.” The book also contains recipes from famed restaurants Tio Pepe, and the defunct Rudy’s 2900 and Chez Fernand. Recipes were also contributed by First Lady Nancy Reagan, and wife of then-Vice President George Bush.

This peach cake recipe was contributed by Mary Jo Krebs, an Arbutus resident who passed away in 2014. Both Mary Jo (born Gibson) and her husband Alcuin had Baltimore city roots going back many generations. Alcuin served in World War II before returning to Baltimore, graduating from Loyola and teaching in Baltimore public schools. 

** So, no, this so-called “Baltimore Peach Cake” is not the yeast-risen, glazed cake we hear so much about. This was another beast entirely; a delicious, moist, cinnamony beast. By any other name it would taste just as sweet.


Join the mailing list

New posts, cookbook photos and latest updates.


Recipe:

Baking ingredients for Baltimore Peach Cake displayed on wooden surface with fresh peaches, flour, butter, sugar, and spices
  • 1 Tablespoon softened butter
  • 1 Cup sugar
  • 2.5 Cup flour
  • 3 Teaspoon baking powder
  • 1.5 Cup milk
  • .75 Cup sugar
  • 2 Teaspoon cinnamon
  • 5 peeled and sliced peach, fresh
  • 2 Tablespoon melted butter

Preheat oven to 350°. Blend first five ingredients with electric mixer.  Spread in greased and floured 13 x 9 inch inch cake pan and sprinkle with one half of cinnamon-sugar. Arrange peach slices in rows on top of the dough. Sprinkle with remaining cinnamon-sugar and drizzle with melted butter. Bake for 25 to 30 minutes.

Recipe adapted from Black-Eyed Susan Country: A Collection of Recipes by St. Agnes Hospital Auxiliary Committee

Fresh peach slices arranged in syrup over cake batter in a blue bowl for Baltimore Peach Cake recipe
Spreading creamy batter into glass dish for peach cake recipe
Baking ingredients for Baltimore Peach Cake with cinnamon sugar in bowl and batter in rectangular pan ready for peaches
Fresh peach slices arranged in rows on cake batter in baking pan for Baltimore Peach Cake recipe
Homemade Baltimore peach cake in baking pan with cinnamon sugar topping and fresh peach slices arranged in rows
Homemade Baltimore Peach Cake with cinnamon sugar topping in glass baking dish after baking
Homemade Baltimore peach cake with cinnamon sugar topping and fresh peach slices arranged in rows
Slice of homemade Baltimore peach cake with cinnamon sugar topping and fresh peaches on white plate with fork

Similar Posts

  • “Fudge-It,” Mary Pat Clarke

    If constituent services is any measure of a councilperson’s effectiveness then there is little debating that Mary Pat Clarke had a long and successful career. I once spoke to Mary Pat Clarke and mentioned that I had seen this recipe, for “Fudge-It,” in “Good things are Cooking in Greater Homewood,” a cookbook produced in 1973 by the GHCC. She professed to not be much of a cook. I have to admit this fudge recipe isn’t the most magical, fudgey candy around, but hey – its in the name.

  • Vanilla Ice Cream

    Nearly all of my old Maryland cook-books contain a few pages of ice cream recipes. It was an integral ‘domestic receipt’ by the time Elizabeth Ellicott Lea published the first Maryland cookbook in 1845. Her book contains a characteristically austere four recipes- less than half as many as later authors M.L. Tyson of “Queen of…

  • Apple Butter

    “Being at the house of a good old German friend in Pennsylvania, in September last, we noticed upon the table what was called apple butter; and finding it an agreeable article, we inquired into the modus operandi in making it, which we give for the gratification of such in New England as may wish to…

  • Chicken in Cucumber Sauce, Ann Grieves

    Ann Grieves was already known for her cooking by the time her recipe appeared in “Private Collection: A Culinary Treasure,” published by the Women’s Committee of the Walter’s Art Gallery. The beautiful hardbound cookbook generated some press, and has enjoyed a relatively decent amount of longevity on Maryland bookshelves, if not Maryland kitchens. With an…